Carry That Weight

I’ve been following the story of Emma Sulkowicz, the Columbia student who is carrying around a mattress everywhere she goes for as long as she has to be on the same campus as her rapist. Emma and two other women filed formal complaints against the same student who raped all three of them. All three cases were dismissed. In a New York Times article, Emma says “the university’s adjudication process left her feeling even more traumatized and unsafe.” She is now one of 27 complainants, who have filed a federal lawsuit against the university for the way it has handled cases of sexual assault in violation of Title IX, Title II, and the Clery Act.

Emma’s story is dredging up painful memories of my first semester as a graduate student at Columbia. Let me preface this by saying I was not raped, and I escaped relatively unscathed, at least physically. I’ve been struggling with how to tell my story, because even after two decades I think back on what happened to me with so many competing emotions: guilt, shame, anger, sorrow…I wish I could figure out a way to tie it all up in a neat bow. I wish I could say that something positive, or at least instructive came of it all. I’m not sure that I can.

The very first person I met at Columbia was Juan, the loud, blustery porter for the building where I was assigned housing. He served as the building’s superintendent and janitor. When my parents and I arrived, he cheerfully helped us transport my things into my new bedroom. I was in a suite that had three bedrooms with a shared kitchen and bathroom. My roommates had not yet arrived.

When it was time for my parents to leave, my lovably guileless, maddening mother turned to thank Juan for his help and added, “Please take good care of my daughter. She doesn’t know anybody in New York. My baby is all alone here. I want you to look out for her.” I knew that my mother was speaking from the depths of purest love, but this did nothing to mitigate my embarrassment.

I went about the business of settling into my new life. I saw Juan around the building on a daily basis and was polite and friendly to him. He was supposed to periodically clean the common areas of all the suites. Since he had keys to all the suites, he would let himself in as he pleased. At first, I thought nothing of this. He was always jovial, and he seemed harmless enough.

When he first suggested that he would show me around the city, I made a vague excuse about being busy with classes.

“You Asian girls like to play hard to get,” was the response I got.

I stiffened when I heard these words, but I let it go. I began to adopt a colder and more formal manner whenever I had to communicate with him.

One day he followed me into my bedroom. This immediately put me on edge. A cockroach scuttled between us and he smashed it with his foot. He lifted his boot toward me and told me to lick it off.

I began to avoid entering and exiting my suite when I thought he might be around. He was always bellowing, so it was fairly easy to know where he was. I did a lot of running to avoid him. If I could hear him on one of the upper floors, I would run out of my building before he could reach the second floor, where I lived. If I heard his voice on the ground floor, I would delay my departure and end up running to class, often arriving late.

Some days it was impossible to avoid him. One day he followed me into my bedroom and wrapped a phone cord around my neck. The next time he followed me into my room, he put his hands around my neck and squeezed hard enough to leave red marks around my neck.

This is the part of the story where I start kicking myself for letting things get to this point. Was I too friendly? Could I have nipped things in the bud by being more assertive? I tend to avoid conflict at all costs. Speaking up for myself is painfully difficult. At first, I was embarrassed. Later, I was scared. At that moment, my instinct for self-preservation kicked in and overrode all else.

“Take your hands off me!” I screamed at him as I jerked free. “Don’t ever touch me again!”

“I’m sorry! I’m sorry! I’m sorry!” he said over and over, as he backed away with his hands in the air. We both knew that he had literally and figuratively crossed the threshold. I knew I’d reached my breaking point.

I went to see the university ombuds person, who expressed alarm at the situation. The head of housing and security were called in. The three administrators told me that I would have to file a formal complaint in order for them to do anything about the situation. They explained to me that there would be a hearing at which Juan and I would be in the same room, at the same table.

“No. I can’t do that,” I answered. “I’m terrified of him. You need to take care of this situation. He’s got keys to my apartment, and he comes into my bedroom whenever he wants to. He’s much bigger than I am and I know he can hurt me.”

They insisted that there was nothing they could do without my help and suggested that I try to enlist other people in the apartment building to support my complaint. When I look back on this dark episode of my life, I think the most painful part of the story is that I could not get a single person to help me. We were all new graduate students in that building. We were a social bunch. We were always visiting each other, trading CDs, and going out to eat together. When I asked these new friends for help, everyone expressed sympathy for me and horror at my predicament, but not one person was willing to write a letter or to join me in filing a formal complaint.

My best hope was an MFA writing student who lived one floor above me, and was the closest thing I had to a friend in New York. He was shocked, concerned, and angry on my behalf, but like everyone else in that building, he too declined to help me write a letter of complaint. The situation turned out to be great fodder for his fiction though. One day he handed me a short story he had written in a hot blaze of inspiration. It would almost have been laughable, if it hadn’t been so damn outrageous. In it, a slutty, spoiled, rich girl falsely accuses a poor, downtrodden character of sexual harassment. A few not-so-subtle allusions compared the accused to a slave. My friend played a part in the sorry drama too. He cast himself as an Abraham Lincoln/liberator figure. When pressured to lend support to the accuser, he nobly refuses to do so. When I threw the story back at him, reeling with hurt and fury, he expressed genuine bewilderment. He denied that there was any connection between the story and my own situation and gently explained, as if to a child, that it was fiction.

My mother had been right about one thing. I really was all alone.

The administrators waged a campaign that felt like harassment of another sort. Every day, at least once and sometimes more than once a day, all three of them would call me, one after the other. They would each pressure me to file a formal complaint, without which, they insisted they were powerless to act. They would say things to me like, “How will you feel, if he rapes a woman and you hadn’t done the right thing?”

They succeeded in making me feel deeply ashamed of myself for not being brave enough to do what Emma Sulkowicz and her two fellow students did recently, but my fear trumped my shame. I dug my heels in and insisted that the university take action to protect me without exposing me to further risk. The thought of having to accuse a man face to face, who could come and go as he pleased into my own bedroom, made me seriously consider abandoning my studies to go home as the better alternative. If just one friend or administrator had been willing to help me bear my load, it would have made all the difference in the world.

It was at this point that I finally reached out to my sister. I couldn’t call my parents. My dad hadn’t let me apply to Columbia for my undergraduate studies, because he thought it would be too dangerous for me to live in the city. I didn’t want them to worry about me, and I was pretty sure that if I told them what was going on, they would show up on my doorstep to preemptively take me back home, whether or not I wanted to leave. My sister and her husband, who also happens to be a bad-ass lawyer, both had several long and heated conversations with the administrators on my behalf. After a week of endless phone calls back and forth, we were at an impasse. In the end, they moved Juan to another building and he was told that he was not allowed to be anywhere on Claremont Avenue. I had to call campus security in a panic just once when I saw him on the street, looking up into the windows. Mercifully, that was the last time I ever saw him.

Eventually, I stopped looking over my shoulder every time I left the building. Eventually, I made true friends who made my last years at Columbia some of the happiest ones of my life: my best friend, who is like another sister to me, and the man who is now my husband. Eventually, I am proud to say that I earned my Ph.D.

A day after I first came upon Emma’s story and video, I saw a new photo. In it, a group of students is carrying the mattress for her. Since her story has become more public, it is rare now that Emma ever has to carry her mattress alone. Last Friday, there was a “Stand with Survivors” rally on Low Plaza. May that continued solidarity and support sustain her through her final year of college.

We live in an imperfect, scary world. Lately the news has been rife with stories of domestic assault. This week Charlottesville has been devastated by the disappearance of an eighteen-year-old UVa student. Some days you just want to lock the doors and hunker down. Is there a lesson in all of this? Is there anything we can do to make things better? The only answers I can come up with seem almost too simple…We can reach out to others. We can take care of one another, as we would care for our own brother or sister. We can do whatever it takes to make sure that no one has to walk alone. And when bad things happen, as they inevitably do, we can make sure that people don’t have to shoulder their burdens alone.

Sweetest 16

Sixteen years ago my sister’s first child, and the first baby in our family was born. That summer we all gathered around her as she slept, staring in silent wonder at the miraculous, perfect little human being that had been sent to us as a gift…

She was so much more than we could have ever wished for. She has continued to enchant us as she has grown.

When she was about six or so, she started to beg for a sibling: “Just one little sister, please!”

This happened:

Again….so much more than anyone could have ever wished for!

To her siblings and to her younger cousins, and to us all really – she is a rockstar:

She has won all kinds of honors and awards:

including playing at Carnegie Hall after winning a piano competition:

The accolades are impressive, of course, but we love her for the kind, sensitive, and generous human being she has become.

Although today is her birthday, we celebrated the event a few weeks ago:

The obligatory photo-fest:

…which became a Cheese-Fest:

The reception:

Speeches:

And a rousing rendition of Happy Birthday to the sweetest 16 year old we know:

Happy birthday! We adore you and hope that all of your wishes (and more!) come true! xoxo

Middle School Graduation Snapshots

On Friday my eldest child graduated from middle school! I am now the proud parent of a high schooler, a middle schooler, and an elementary schooler.

My middle school graduate and his friends let loose with a celebratory game of tug-of-war.

With his younger brother.

Upon discovering this photo, said younger brother asked me with great indignation, “So, instead of saving your son, you took photos?!

Yup.

NYC, Marathon Day 2 continued

Our New York adventure continued after the Met with lunch at Uva, an Italian restaurant at 2nd Avenue between E. 77th and 78th Street. There’s a lovely patio with a retractable roof at the back of the restaurant. And here’s my lovely friend, politely posing for yet another photo when I’m sure she’d secretly like to whack me over the head with the menu!

After lunch, we made our way to Broadway, where we saw the musical Once. 

Before the show begins, the audience can go up on stage and order a drink from the bar, which is also the set. The cast performs songs on stage while the audience finds their seats.

The talented actors/musicians inject as much life as they can into a rather lugubrious story line and score. What’s particularly impressive is that each cast member not only sings, but also plays one or more of their own instruments, precluding the need for a pit orchestra. Not sure they pulled off the Irish and Czech accents though.

We strolled past a fixture of Times Square, “The Naked Cowboy,” :

IMG_8814and had dinner at Má pêche, a David Chang Momofuku restaurant at 15 West 56th Street between 5th and 6th Avenues in the Chambers Hotel. I loved the vegetable rice cakes:

The photo does not do the dish justice. It was made out of sliced tteok cylinders, the kind usually used for tteokboki. Instead of spicy red sauce, it was marinated with a more subtle, umami-vegetable- mushroom-laced sauce. The lobster fried rice, seasoned with duck fat, was pretty incredible too:

To my dismay, I have become one of those people who not only annoys my friends and family by constantly taking pictures of them, but who also takes pictures of my food. Ick.

Tomorrow – one more New York post with no food photos. Promise.

She Was (not) a Dancing Queen

In my last post I wrote of my ignominious history with Physical Education, and in particular, about the kayaking debacle in which I almost killed my first college P.E. teacher. After three terrifying kayak sessions, I came to my senses and slunk back to where I belonged…a Beginner Aerobics class.

Don’t imagine for a moment that this aerobics class didn’t also hold its own challenges for me. It’s not something I like to talk about, but I suffer from S.K.I.: Severe Kinetic Ineptitude. I’m clumsy, prone to falling, and find it extremely challenging to mimic physical movements. Despite these serious limitations, I managed to plod and stumble my way through the first quarter of aerobics. I gazed with real satisfaction at that first CR (credit) on my report card.

Emboldened by this modest success, the next quarter I signed up for another aerobics class. In my overweening arrogance, I thought I could slack off a bit. I began to miss a class here or there. No big deal…until I missed one too many classes to earn my P.E. credit. I didn’t worry too much about this. I still had four years to take the two more classes I needed to fulfill the phys ed requirement. I figured the credit would simply not show up on my transcript. Imagine my surprise when I found an “F” for Beginner Aerobics on my report card. The shame of it was almost too much to bear. Despite the fact that the failing grade did not count towards my G.P.A., my mother was livid. I resolved to sign up for Jazz dance the following quarter. It would be so much fun, I wouldn’t want to miss a single class!

Have I ever mentioned that I am a spectacularly bad dancer? In high school I used to be in all the musicals. I could sing, I could sort of act, but I most definitely could not dance. For big dance numbers when the whole cast was on stage, the choreographer would hide me in the back row where my graceless flailing wouldn’t be so visible. Sometimes there would be others back there with me. We back row dancers never had to move our feet at all. Occasionally we would be assigned a dead-simple semaphore-like movement to perform with our arms to justify our presence on stage. The choreographer charitably dubbed us “the disco line.” During performances I would grimly fix my gaze into the distance as I performed my moves, pretending not to notice my family members in the audience, poking each other and pointing at me as they squirmed and gasped and yelped in paroxysms of helpless laughter.

I boldly showed up to my first jazz dance class ready to leave my sorry terpsichorean past behind me. I came wearing a ratty t-shirt, shorts, and sneakers and was slightly dismayed to see that everyone else was sporting leotards, leggings, and jazz shoes. The teacher began showing us some basic jazz moves. She eased into things by teaching us how to do “jazz hands.” I have to admit, I was pretty damn amazing at “jazz hands.” I actually kind of blew myself away. She taught us a few more moves. “Step touch” – a piece of cake! A “jazz square” was a little more complicated, but just about manageable. “Step, ball, change” – yes! Chassé – got it! She had us practice these basic moves for about half the class.

It was going pretty well, though she wouldn’t stop squawking at me.

“Adrienne! Relax your shoulders!…RELAX your shoulders.”

At one point, clearly exasperated, she stomped over to me and said as she forcefully pressed down on my shoulders, “Re-LAX your shoulders!”

Suddenly, a surprised expression dawned on her face, “Oh…you have really broad shoulders. Kind of like a football player.”

At that moment, a deeply suppressed memory from my high school days came flooding back into my mind. One day, my dad questioned me about what I wanted to do with my life. I had no answer for him, so I flippantly tossed off the most preposterous thing I could think of…

“I’m going to be a go-go dancer, Dad!”

A pained look passed over his face.

“Adrienne,” he said solemnly, gently, and with the utmost kindness, “to be a dancer, you have to have a fancy body. You don’t have a fancy body.”

Just as I had back then, I soldiered on.

“OK, class! Now we’re going to have some fun! We’re going to put these moves together into a dance sequence!”

The teacher shimmied and pirouetted, kicked and pranced across the gym floor as she called out the moves she was performing.

“It’s your turn now. Form a line and go one at a time. 5! 6! 7! 8! Jump lunge, hitch kick, chassé, cross, side kick, barrel turn, kick, ball change, step touch, step touch, soutane piqué, chaîné, aaaaaaaand jazz hands!”

This was, without a shadow of a doubt, even more horrifying than having to hang upside down in a kayak in the icy cold Connecticut River.

One by one my classmates strutted and danced across the floor with bored expressions on their faces, expertly executing the sequence like a whole chorus line of Bob Fosse protégés.

When it was my turn, I lumbered through the moves like a drunken ox. (I did finish strong, however, with my awesome “jazz hands”). The room grew silent. My classmates gazed intently at the ceiling, at a piece of lint they suddenly discovered on their leotard, at the floor…As for my teacher, she said nothing, but stood there with a thoughtful and slightly stunned expression on her face. Somehow or other, I managed to get through enough of these torture sessions to get another P.E. credit under my belt. Eventually, I got my third and final P.E. credit after one last round of Beginner Aerobics.

Hope you have a wonderful, wonderful weekend and week. I’m leaving today to go to Korea for work. My sister’s coming with me, so I’ll get to play too! I’ll be back in a week with photos and more stories…See you then!

Kayaking: or, How I almost killed my P.E. teacher

I’ve had a long and chequered past with Physical Education, but I hit my nadir at Dartmouth. There were a couple phys ed requirements for graduation. First, every student had to pass a swimming test. On my first day on campus, I swam the required lap and promptly lost my contact lens in the pool. I fared no better at the second requirement, which was to take three P.E. classes.

The array of options was astounding. Sure, you could do something pedestrian like aerobics. But what kind of boob would choose to do something like that when you could do skiing, fencing, or water polo for P.E. credit?! My eyes lit up when I saw kayaking on the list of possible classes. Although I had never done any kayaking before, I was sure it couldn’t be difficult. In my mind, I envisioned myself peacefully floating down the Connecticut River, taking in the scenery as I gently rowed along, all while earning a P.E. credit with practically no effort on my part. It was the obvious choice for an out of shape, unathletic couch potato like myself.

I showed up at the docks on the first day of class wearing a wool sweater as I had been instructed. We got our kayaks into the water and the hour passed by just as I had imagined it. It was one of those perfect, crisp Fall days in New Hampshire. I couldn’t believe how lucky I was to be checking off a mandatory requirement in such a thoroughly pleasant way. As we rowed back to the river’s edge at the end of the class, I congratulated myself on having stayed upright in my kayak. I congratulated myself on so cleverly figuring out how to get P.E. credit without having to break a sweat.

And then one of the instructors announced that it was time to learn how to do a wet exit. I was horrified as I listened to him describe what this would entail and then watch as he actually demonstrated the technique himself. A wet exit meant that I would have to deliberately flip the kayak I had so proudly managed to keep upright for the whole class upside down. Hanging upside down in the water?! This was the stuff of my worst nightmares! I had to then pull open the spray skirt that had kept my bottom half nice and dry during my little jaunt down the river, and then swim out from the kayak into the icy cold river.

I managed to quell the panic attack induced by being upside down in water. (It’s also very possible that I was just stupefied by the freezing cold). When the instructor demonstrated the maneuver for us, he had swum out from his kayak like a sleek otter, his head serenely bobbing up out of the water. I pulled the spray skirt open and fell heavily onto the jagged rocks. I blindly scrabbled against the rocks with my eyes tightly shut (trying not to lose yet another contact lens) before finally getting my bearings. I made my way back to the surface, glugging, snorting, and choking in a most undignified manner. I staggered back to my dorm room trailing behind me: blood, river water, and my sorry, deflated delusions of an easy P.E. credit.

The wet exit had been traumatic, but I figured I could just about handle it. I’d done it once, I could do it again. The next class went by much as the first had, but this time the hour spent floating down the river was marred by the knowledge of what was to come. I braced myself as we rowed again to the river’s edge at the end of the class.

“Today we’re going to do C-rolls,” the instructor chirped. He proceeded to demonstrate how we would deliberately flip our kayaks sideways into the water and then right ourselves by using our torsos to propel ourselves out of the water. We did it multiple times on our left sides. And then to even things out, we did it multiple times on our right sides. Our instructor told us that we would work our way up to complete rolls in the water. When our torsos were completely soaked and numb, we finished the job on our lower halves by doing another wet exit.

I thought it could get no worse. I was wrong. On the third class the instructors informed us that we were going to learn how to do a rescue. They demonstrated this by having one of the instructors flip himself upside down in the water. He tapped with his hands against the hull of his boat to indicate that he needed help. The second instructor expertly maneuvered his kayak so that the front of it hit the upside down kayak close to the tapping hands. The upside down instructor placed his hands on the kayak and used it for leverage to right himself.

“Now it’s your turn,” the rescued instructor said. There were a dozen other people in that class, but he looked straight at me. “I’ll flip upside down again and when you see me tapping my hull, you’ll gently bump the front of your kayak as close to my hands as you can.”

Before I had a chance to demur, he flipped upside down in the water. He began tapping the side of his boat with his hands. I tried to maneuver my kayak to where he was. The tapping got faster. I still couldn’t manage to get my kayak to touch his. The tapping gained a distinctly frantic edge to it. I desperately tried, but failed again and again to get my kayak to touch his. Finally, the second instructor nosed his kayak into position and the upside down instructor righted himself. He no longer looked like a sleek, serene otter. He looked pretty pissed, in fact. He ended the class by grimly announcing that we would all be practicing rescues on each other next time.

I switched to aerobics that afternoon.

It’s Cold

Part I: It’s cold. It’s freezing. We’ve been saying the same two sentences all week long. Tired of repeating the same old hackneyed phrases? Here are some more colorful alternatives:

The Brassy Option

It’s colder than a witch’s teat in a brass bra.

It’s colder than a brass toilet seat on the shady side of an iceberg.

It’s cold enough to freeze the tail* off a brass monkey. *(Frequently substituted with spherically shaped male part of the anatomy).

It’s colder than a gravedigger’s shovel.* (Frequently substituted with word that rhymes with “brass”).

The Classy Option

“When the breath freezes into ice dust and falls almost silently to the ground, Siberians call it the whisper of stars.” from David K. Shipler’s Russia: Broken Idols, Solemn Dreams.

Part II: It could always be worse:

Here’s a reading suggestion that will put your shivering into perspective. Evgenii Zamiatin’s short story “The Cave” is about a couple trying to survive in an unheated apartment in the dead of winter. Post-revolutionary Petrograd is depicted as a prehistoric landscape of glaciers and woolly mammoths. The bitter cold drives the couple to desperate acts. The story is deeply depressing, of course. It is Russian literature after all. I know this doesn’t sound like much of a recommendation, but it’s a great story and I can guarantee you it will make you feel like you’re not so cold after all…If you have access to JSTOR, you can read the full text there for free. Otherwise, it’s in The Portable Twentieth-Century Russian Reader.

I spent the four coldest years of my life during my college days in frigid New Hampshire. I would run as fast as I could between classes trying to minimize my exposure…and there are very few things I hate more than running. As soon as the air hit my face, my ears would burn with an icy fire. The snot dripping from my nose would turn into miniature icicles. My eyes would start to water, the tears would freeze my eyelashes, and I would hear an icy tinkle every time I blinked. At least it’s not that cold…unless you’re reading this in New Hampshire.

It’s been widely reported recently that it’s colder in Winnipeg than it is on the surface of Mars. Again: no comfort at all if you happen to be reading this in Winnipeg.

And for more perspective…at least we didn’t get 26 inches of snow like we did in 2009!

Stay warm out there and have a wonderful weekend!

Unicorn Meat

Did Santa bring your kids sugarplums this Christmas? Ours got unicorn meat in their stockings!

There are lots and lots of reviews of this product on Amazon, including one by George Takei. You can read them here. I promise you, they are highly entertaining!

But perhaps not quite as entertaining as the kids’ reactions when they discovered what was inside the cans:

Happy weekend!

Goodness.

This weekend I was feeling distressed about the bad behavior, which led to the demise of the Helping Hands service group I had helped found about eight years ago. I decided to refocus my thoughts on people who inspire me. Fortunately, there are many of these people in my life, including the many children who have participated in Helping Hands over the years.

There are people like my friend Rosita, who as PTO president of her school in Madison, Wisconsin used funds to make sure every single child at her economically diverse school had a pair of snow pants. She refused to make the yearbook a fundraiser as is common practice, because she felt that every child, whether or not he or she could afford it, should be able to have one.

There are people like my dear friend Janel, whose every word and action somehow seem like acts of kindness:

IMG_2772

And then of course, there’s my own mother, who won’t spend a penny on herself, so she can give lavishly to others.

Here are a few more stories I’ve been thinking about…

When my friend Amanda came to visit for a few hours over the holidays, we got caught up on what we’d been up to in our professional lives. I expressed sadness over my inability to provide meaningful help in some of the harder cases I had been dealing with at work. She responded by telling me the story of a nineteen year old she knew when she was about the same age, who was working in a hospice. When she asked him how he could bear to work in a place where he couldn’t really do anything to help the people who were there, he responded with a wisdom far beyond what you would expect of a teenage boy:

“That’s where you’re wrong. You can always do something to help. You can adjust a pillow. You can hold a hand. You can make a person feel less lonely by sitting with them.”

Those words, uttered decades ago by a nineteen year old I’ll probably never know, took my breath away. I’ll remember them for the rest of my life.

And then I asked Amanda what she had been up to. “The lunatic, the lover, and the poet…of imagination all compact” is my friend Amanda. She’s a professional medical writer and an incredible poet, who is always cooking up extracurricular benevolence projects. The last time we met up, she told me about how she’d been visiting sketchy neighborhoods late at night to meet up with prostitutes. She tries to get them the help they need to get out of the terrible situations they are in, whether by driving them to rehab or by finding them work clothes for job interviews.

“Sometimes, they don’t want to be helped. Some nights, all I can do for them is to buy them a hamburger. So that’s what I do.”

Now she’s expanded her scope to help longterm unemployed people. Don’t ask me how she does it, but she’s bringing people together to start up their own businesses. She’s pounding the pavement and meeting with lawmakers to make things happen.

And finally, there’s my friend and erstwhile co-leader of Helping Hands, Annika. We were emailing back and forth as we made the hard decision to give up the fight. As we came to our sad conclusion, I sent her one more message to thank her for all she had done. I shared with her my vague fantasy that we could open up some kind of business, because working with her has always been a joy.

In her reply, she told me that she had been fantasizing about the same thing when the lottery was getting so big a few weeks ago! I’m not going to lie…I had a few ideas about what I’d do myself, in the unlikely event that I would actually ever buy a ticket and in the even unlikelier event that I won. Me? I thought about debts that would get paid off, maybe getting a really nice camera…But Annika‘s idea for when she hit it big was that we would take all those millions of dollars….and open our own non-profit charity. Goodness.

Today on my way home from work, the skies were dark. As I stopped off at the pharmacy to refill a prescription, I realized there was a rainbow in the sky. A sign? I pulled out my camera set to autofocus and tried to take a picture. Every time I pressed the shutter button, the rainbow would disappear. Finally, I switched to manual focus and got the photo:

Sometimes, it just takes a little more effort to readjust your focus to capture the beauty that’s there.

O miserable, miserable/And yet…

O miserable, miserable!

The first part of this overly long and tedious post is, frankly, a big fat downer, but I have to get it out of my system. Feel free to skip to the “And yet” part. I probably would, if I were you.

This has been a heartbreaking weekend. The Helping Hands service group I helped found at my children’s elementary school eight years ago, came to a premature end on Friday. Not for a lack of participants and willing teachers. Not because the group wasn’t something our school was proud to have. Certainly not for a lack of resources…We have a lot of generous (and truth be told – affluent) parents at our school, who have contributed thousands and thousands of dollars to a PTO that is supposed to represent our interests.

Until this year, we had always been reimbursed by the PTO to cover basic operating costs, which never came to more than a hundred dollars a session, and usually well below that. The cost of this program was low, because teachers have always volunteered to lead the program. We have never charged for the class, because we strongly felt that it would go against the very spirit of the program to charge families to participate. Because we didn’t charge a fee, we were able to be inclusive of the very few kids at our school, who wouldn’t have otherwise been able to afford to participate. Over the years, we have engaged in fundraising for disaster relief, for the Blue Ridge Area Food Bank, for an orphanage and school in Haiti, the list goes on and on. One thing we’ve never had to raise funds for is to cover our own operating costs. Why would we, when we are part of a school, whose PTO has tens of thousands of dollars in its groaning coffers? Until last year, I trustingly wrote checks to the organization every single year, like most of the other parents at our school do.

Last year, our Helping Hands group was facing a large shipping bill to send a donation of clothing to the Ford Haitian Orphanage. Knowing that the PTO had carried over a large sum of money from the year before, we applied for a PTO grant to cover the cost. In doing so, we inadvertently ignited a controversy. The board felt that money should not go “outside of our own school.” We brought a room full of parents to a usually sparsely attended PTO meeting. They spoke up for us to say that they could see that spending money to ship donations our group had collected would be just as much an investment in our own children as it would be for children in Haiti. If a vote had been permitted, our project would have been fully funded. What an empowering and valuable lesson it would have been to show our children how an ethical community behaves. Those who have share with those who don’t…or should anyway. How wonderful it would have been for our children to see the adults in their lives modeling as generous behavior as they themselves were when they set out to help others outside of our own school. Instead, we were told that a vote would not even be allowed.

After a lot of rancor and wrangling, the outcome of the controversy was that we held a fundraiser. The money raised allowed us to send our clothing donation and also to give donations on behalf of our school to organizations that meant something to our kids. They voted to give money to the Hope Community Center, the PACEM  homeless shelter, SHE (a shelter for battered women), the SPCA, the Wildlife Center, and the Ford Haitian Orphanage. In addition, we were asked to submit a request for next year’s budget. We optimistically requested $1200. We were given $50.  We assumed that the fifty dollars would be for special projects or expenses beyond the basic ones. On Friday the PTO let us know by way of an email informing us that we are $47.41 over budget, that it will now no longer cover our basic operating costs. We can only conclude that this is a punitive measure for calling out the board on how it manages its our money.

When we tried to navigate the system, the rules were arbitrarily changed. We hoped for a change in leadership for the following year and waited for an announcement calling for nominations for a new executive board to be voted into office. Instead, we got an announcement that the board members had basically reappointed themselves in reshuffled positions. At this point, my co-leader Annika and I are throwing in the towel. Pounding your own head against a brick wall is just stupid. I wrote my very last check to the PTO today for exactly $47.41.

And yet…

Our aim has been to show kids that no matter how small or how young they are, they can make a positive difference in this world. Over the years we’ve done projects around our school from raking leaves to cleaning paths. We’ve done projects in our own community from collecting money and supplies for schools in a neighboring county whose buildings were destroyed in an earthquake to helping set up cots for a temporary homeless shelter. We’ve done projects that have taken our kids out into the wide world to visit far-flung places like Afghanistan and Haiti through their charitable giving. Through all of these experiences these children have learned what a difference a penny makes, what a difference an open heart makes, what a difference a willingness to help others makes.